Can you redeem Reward Points on a recurring order? SFB Coffee June 27, 2017 22:26 Updated Follow Unfortunately, the only payment method accepted for recurring orders is a credit card (Discover, American Express, Visa, or Mastercard). Related articles How do I sign-up for Subscribe to Save? Do I receive Free Shipping on each recurring order? What are the benefits in joining Subscribe to Save? How can I make changes to my existing Subscribe to Save recurring order? What are the discounts that you can earn or receive? Comments 0 comments Article is closed for comments.